Koi bhi tax logon ko pasand nahi aata, lekin har unpopular tax unconstitutional nahi hota. Jab citizens tax law challenge karte hain, to courts kuch limited grounds hi examine karte hain:
- Legislative competence – kya sahi legislature ne banaya?
- Fundamental rights violation – specially equality (arbitrary classification) ya trade freedom,
- Confiscatory nature – kya tax practically property snatch kar raha hai,
- Double taxation / clear discrimination without reason.
Policy wisdom (“ye tax economy ke liye bura hai”) usually court ka domain nahi; yeh Parliament/government ki responsibility hai. Court bas yeh dekhta hai ki framework reasonable, non-arbitrary, and legal boundaries ke andar hai ya nahi.
Taxpayers ke liye best approach ye hai ki compliance ke sath-sath industry body, representation, aur consultative forums use karein. Pure judicial route expensive, slow, aur uncertain hota hai, although extreme injustice wale cases me yahi akhri remedy hoti hai.
